Miss Julie, Death Takes a Holiday

This is the place to talk about films from around the world.

Miss Julie, Death Takes a Holiday

Postby howardschumann(d) » Mon Jan 15, 2007 4:50 pm

MISS JULIE (Frken Julie)

Directed by Alf Sjoberg (1951), 90 minutes

Based on a well-known play by August Strindberg, Alf Sjobergs Miss Julie depicts the struggle for survival between classes and genders in late 19th century Sweden that leads to confusion and tragedy. Because of its frank portrayal of sex between a lower-class servant and an upper-class aristocrat, the play was banned in Europe until 1906 and in Britain until 1939. It is highly regarded, however, as an important work in the literary genre that became known as Naturalism. Compellingly played by Anita Bjork who completely captures her characters erratic willfulness, Miss Julie, the 25-year old daughter of Count Carl (Anders Henrikson) is estranged from the society in which she grew up and fights against the restrictions placed on her because of her status.

Julie is a rebel who treats social conventions of the time with disdain, though she still demands to be treated as a proper woman. Having recently broken up with her fianc (Kurt-Olof Sundstrm) after what would now be called an S&M incident in which she literally makes him jump through hoops like a trained dog, she is open for sexual adventure. The adventure she finds takes the form of the handsome butler Jean (Ulf Palme) whom she seduces following the drunken revelries celebrating Midsummer Eve, a pagan ritual. It is an act which, though only mildly reprehensible today, was viewed as depraved in Strindbergs time and led to the authors characterization of Julie as being sick.

Although Jean is engaged to the cook, Christine (Marta Dorff), neither Jean nor his fianc object because they see the act as an honor due to Julies social position. The seduction, however, leads to her loss of respect from the servants as well as the loss of her own self respect. To escape from their untenable situation, the two lovers talk about leaving on the next train to Switzerland where Jean fantasizes about owning a hotel but the tangled web they have woven leads to unforeseen consequences.

One of the highlights of the film for me was the seamless inter-mixing of dream intervals and flashbacks from childhood. In her dream, Miss Julie is high up on a ledge or mountain. She can no longer hold on but lacks the courage to come down, though she has a longing to fall. Jean, on the other hand, wants to climb a high tree but is unable to reach the top. In flashbacks, Miss Julie recalls how her mother Berta (Lissi Alandh) saw herself as a feminist who was opposed to marriage and only wanted to be the counts mistress. When she gave birth to a daughter, she exacted her revenge by raising the girl as a boy and carrying on various misdeeds until the estate went bankrupt.

Despite its anachronistic and morbid social outlook, Sjobergs Miss Julie is not a grim experience. The director lightens it up considerably with country scenes of folk dancing, horseback riding, and rowing, all in an idyllic setting, beautifully photographed by Goran Strindberg. Though it reflects Strindbergs distorted view of women as hysterics, Miss Julie is a superb film and a treat for the senses, both visually magnificent and wonderfully performed. It has a well-deserved reputation as being one of the greatest Swedish films of all time.

GRADE: A

DEATH TAKES A HOLIDAY

Directed by Mitchell Leisen (1934), 78 minutes

Because I could not stop for Death, he kindly stopped for me; the carriage held but just ourselves and immortality Emily Dickinson

If Death took a holiday, the guns would go silent in Iraq, the slaughter on our nations highways would cease, and the news media would be compelled to cover positive events in the humanities, arts, and sciences. Unfortunately, Death has not had a vacation in recorded history, but Mitchell Leisens 1934 fantasy, Death Takes a Holiday, allows us to consider the possibility. Co-written by Maxwell Anderson and Gladys Lehman and based on the play "La Morte in Vacanza" by Alberto Casella, Death Takes a Holiday stars Frederic March as the Grim Reaper who takes on human form in an attempt to discover why men fear him so much. Why he has waited 5,000 years to satisfy this curiosity is not explained.

After a brief tryout as a shadowy figure who scares the daylights out of those that cross his path, Death shows up at, of all places, an upscale party at an Italian villa, posing as the mysterious Prince Sirki. Only one person knows who he really is, the host Duke Lambert (Guy Standing), and he is sworn to secrecy. Sirki proceeds to fascinate the guests. Given to bursts of wit and poetry, he can just as quickly turn sullen and threatening, and some soon find out that it is better not to look too deeply into his eyes. During the three days in which the Prince is at the villa, however, people all over the world miraculously escape death and potential suicides are doomed to frustration.

To see whats behind all the conversation about love, the suave but nave Prince Sirki falls for the irresistible Grazia (Evelyn Venable), the daughter of one of Dukes friends. Grazia knows who Death is but does not fear him, much to the chagrin of her fianc, Corrado (Kent Taylor) who has developed a strong disdain for Prince Charming. More sinister than Brad Pitt in the 1998 remake Meet Joe Black, March turns in a very convincing performance as the creepy yet strangely appealing guest. Although the ending is melodramatic, the emotions are very real and the suggestion that Death may in reality be a friend disguised as a foe is quite touching.

GRADE: B+
howardschumann(d)
 


Re: Miss Julie, Death Takes a Holiday

Postby A » Wed Jan 17, 2007 6:09 pm

I have just recently watched "Miss Julie", thanks to a friendly americna who send me a DVD copy via mail.
Up until the scene when Julie and Jean sleep together the film is aspiring to greatness, but after that, Strindberg rears his ugly head too much for my tastes, with rather poor textbook psychology and a completely misguided attitude towards women. Though the film has a lot going for it, and I will certainly watch it again in the future. Judging by some of the shots, I think Sjoberg would have also been an excellent silent director. The close-ups are even more stunning than in Hitchcock's films.
Nevertheless I would give the film a negative rating. Probably C - (on my scale it was a 47 out of 100).
A
 

Re: Miss Julie, Death Takes a Holiday

Postby howardschumann(d) » Wed Jan 17, 2007 8:45 pm

I can understand how you feel. However, I was aware of Strindberg's attitudes going into the film and I tried not to let them get in the way of my appreciating the film on its own merits.
howardschumann(d)
 

Re: Miss Julie, Death Takes a Holiday

Postby A » Fri Jan 19, 2007 7:05 pm

Well, I know enough now before my next viewing of it. And when another Strindberg adaptation comes along, I'll try to be lenient.
Nevertheless I can never distinguish a films form from its content. To me theay are essentially one and the same, each reflecting on the other. So if one doesn't work, there is no way a film is going to be good, no matter how great some aspects might be.
A
 


Return to Film Talk

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest